Write amplification test

Data reduction works by taking advantage of the entropy, or randomness, of data. And all of these separate tests require separate preconditioning.

Understanding SSDs: Why SSDs hate write amplification

We do this by compacting all the sstables in L0 together with all the sstables in L1. The reason why is explained more fully in the next section on The Potential Pitfalls write amplification test SSD Benchmark Testing, which also explores other common problems, as well how to avoid and detect them.

Write amplification

It then finds the roughly 10 sstables in the next higher level which overlap with this sstable, and compacts them against the one input sstable.

Because all of these inherent limitations can be overcome by following a set of best test practices covered in the next sectionthe three leading causes of meaningless or misleading benchmark test results involve the operator.

Iometer is the best benchmark for testing known target applications because it enables the use of actual data. Therefore, separating the data will enable static data to stay at rest and if it never gets rewritten it will have the lowest possible write amplification for that data.

The SSD Relapse: Understanding and Choosing the Best SSD

Two steps are critical to ensuring that the SSDs are properly preconditioned. The next post in this series will introduce a new compaction strategy, Hybrid Compaction Strategy, which aims to solve, or at least mitigate both problems. If the user saves data consuming only half of the total user capacity of the drive, the other half of the user capacity will look like additional over-provisioning as long as the TRIM command is supported in the system.

But if we ask Scylla for the counter of bytes written to disk during this experiment, we get 50 GB. One particularly good case for LCS is a write workload with high time locality, where recently-written data has a high probability of being modified again soon, and where the events of adding completely new data or modifying very old data are relatively infrequent.

The multi-faceted power of data reduction technology A previous discussion on data reduction Read: But the more interesting — and typical — case is a mixed workload with a combination of reads and writes. The benefit would be realized only after each run of that utility by the user. In this way the old data cannot be read anymore, as it cannot be decrypted.

This is, of course, a great result — compare it to the almost 8-fold space amplification we saw in the previous post for STCS! The first example was straightforward writing of new data at a constant pace, and we saw high temporary disk space use during compaction — at some points doubling the amount of disk space needed.

Leveled compaction indeed does this, but its cleverness is how it does it: Reading the Results A brand new or freshly-erased SSD exhibits astonishing performance, because there is no need to move any old data before writing new data.

A very low percentage of reads could be equally meaningless, as that reveals very little differentiation among the SSDs in this particular test. The other extreme is a read-only workload or one with very rare updates.

However, with the right tests, you can sometimes extrapolate, with some accuracy, the WA value. So this a rare instance when an amplifier — namely, Write Amplification — makes something smaller.

Separate tests with separate preconditioning must be performed for sequential and random data access. This is not surprising considering that external sorting has O N logN complexity. The best case for LCS is that the last level is filled.

Testing Samsung 850 Pro Endurance & Measuring V-NAND Die Size

In this way the old data cannot be read anymore, as it cannot be decrypted. It was first introduced in Cassandra 1. While STCS may need to do huge compactions and temporarily have both input and output on disk, LCS always does small compaction steps, involving roughly 11 input and output sstables of a fixed size.

Instead, SSDs use a process called garbage collection GC to reclaim the space taken by previously stored data. SSDs without data reduction technology do not benefit from entropy, so the level of entropy used on them does not matter.

More likely, the results are way off, way too often. LCS picks one sstable, with size X, to compact. For some types of write-heavy workloads, these high write amplification numbers are not reached in practice: The result is the SSD will have more free space enabling lower write amplification and higher performance.

But, it turns out that the write amplification for Leveled Compaction Strategy is even worse. The other major contributor to WA is the organization of the free space. Note that as the data size grows, the number of tiers, and therefore the write amplification, will grow logarithmically O logN.

Although you can manually recreate this condition with a secure erase, the cost is an additional write cycle, which defeats the purpose. The other major contributor to WA is the organization of the free space. With sequential writes, generally all the data in the pages of the block becomes invalid at the same time.

Scylla’s Compaction Strategies Series: Write Amplification in Leveled Compaction

The situation is very different for random data.Write amplification is always higher than because we write each piece of data to the commit-log, and then write it again to an sstable, and then each time compaction involves this piece of data and copies it to a new sstable, that’s another write.


Testing Samsung Pro Endurance & Measuring V-NAND Die Size I decided to see what the worst-case write amplification looks like. The test regime is similar to the endurance testing but the. Why is it important to know your SSD write amplification? At the end of the test period, print out the SMART attributes again and look for all attributes that have a.

Minimizing write amplification with a data reduction technology increases both performance and endurance, and reduces power consumption. Data reduction works by taking advantage of the entropy, or randomness, of data. If you have an SSD with the type of data reduction technology used in Seagate’s SandForce controller, you will see lower and lower write amplification as you approach your lowest data entropy when you test with any entropy lower than %.

Write amplification test
Rated 5/5 based on 60 review